Using the Internet to manage headache in children
The benefits of 2 self-help training programs (multimodal cognitive-behavioral training [CBT] and applied relaxation [AR]) presented via the Internet were compared by researchers from the University of Göttingen, in Germany.
First, the details.
- 65 children and adolescents (average age: 13 years) with recurrent headache (at least 2 per month) were assigned to a treatment group.
- CBT presented via the Internet
- AR presented via the Internet
- Educational intervention not involving the Internet
- Changes in headache frequency, intensity, duration and frequency were recorded.
- Pain catastrophizing and general well-being (depression, psychopathological symptoms, and health-related quality of life) were also reported.
And, the results.
- All groups had a significant reduction in headache frequency, duration, and pain catastrophizing.
- There were no differences in headache intensity, depression, psychopathological symptoms, or health-related quality of life.
- Rates of response by the end of treatment were 63% for CBT, 32% with AR, and 19% for educational intervention.
- Statistical analysis of the results show that it requires 2 people to be treated with CBT for 1 person to benefit, vs 5 for AR and educational intervention.
- At follow-up, no significant differences were found (CBT: 63%, AR: 56%, educational intervention: 55%).
The bottom line?
The abstract is short on details. For example it fails to tell us the duration of treatment and the timing of follow-up.
That said, in this study, children and adolescents treated with CBT showed improvement in headache frequency, duration, and pain catastrophizing.
And these results are supported by other studies of Internet-based treatment. Researchers from the Netherlands and Sweden recently conducted a review of 12 studies and concluded, “Internet interventions targeting pain were comparable to the effects found for face-to-face treatments, and the same was true for interventions aimed at headache.”
Offering CBT through the Internet potentially saves therapist time, reduces waiting-lists, eliminates travel time, and provides an opportunity to reach patients who can’t easily access more traditional forms of treatments. What’s needed is a study to confirm these benefits in order to make the Internet more available as a reimbursed healthcare service.
4/24/10 17:13 JR